Link to full podcast episode here:

Top 3 Mistakes Home Sellers Make in San Luis Obispo County

Selling your home is one of the largest financial decisions you will ever make, yet many sellers unknowingly make mistakes that cost them tens of thousands of dollars. In this episode of the Happy House Hacking Podcast, hosts Owen and Camille Schwaegerle break down the three most common mistakes home sellers make in San Luis Obispo County and explain how to avoid them so you can protect your equity and sell with confidence.

Whether you are downsizing, relocating, or preparing for your next investment, this episode offers practical, experience-backed guidance to help you position your home as a strong, sellable asset in today’s market.

The Spark Behind the Conversation

Owen and Camille see these mistakes play out every week. Listings that sit too long, homes that require repeated price reductions, and sellers who leave money on the table simply because the strategy was wrong from the start.

As Camille explains, “This could cost you tens of thousands of dollars,” especially when sellers rely on outdated assumptions from the ultra-competitive markets of 2020 and 2021. With inventory rising and buyers becoming more selective, sellers must adapt to a new reality.

Defining the Core Issue

The core issue sellers face today is misunderstanding the current market and overestimating what buyers are willing to pay without preparation. Homes are no longer selling simply because they exist. Buyers are educated, informed, and cautious.

Owen puts it plainly: sellers are still stuck in a mindset that no longer reflects reality, and that disconnect leads directly to missed opportunities and lost equity. 

This matters because your home is not just a place you lived. Once it hits the market, it becomes a financial asset, and assets must be positioned correctly to perform well.

Breaking It Down: The Three Biggest Seller Mistakes

1. Overpricing the Home

Overpricing is the number one mistake sellers make. Many believe starting high gives them room to negotiate, but today’s buyers have instant access to pricing data, comparable sales, and automated valuations.

Camille explains that buyers often interpret an overpriced home as a red flag rather than an opportunity. Multiple price reductions create suspicion, not leverage.

Takeaway: Pricing correctly from day one attracts attention, creates momentum, and often leads to stronger offers. Overpricing repels buyers and increases the likelihood your listing will expire or sell for less than market value.

2. Ignoring Deferred Maintenance

The second major mistake is selling a home with visible deferred maintenance. Small issues like dry rot, worn flooring, peeling paint, or neglected landscaping speak loudly to buyers.

As Owen notes, buyers already feel financially stretched. When they see repairs, they mentally inflate the cost and discount their offer accordingly.

Camille adds that even modest investments, such as five to ten thousand dollars in updates, can dramatically improve perceived value and buyer confidence.

Takeaway: Buyers will always discount more than the actual cost of repairs. Addressing maintenance upfront almost always delivers a higher return than selling as-is.

3. Choosing the Wrong Agent

The third and often most costly mistake is selecting the wrong real estate agent. Marketing, photography, pricing strategy, and negotiation all hinge on the professional representing you.

Owen emphasizes that poor presentation online can prevent buyers from ever stepping through the door. Dark photos, cluttered rooms, or low-effort listings directly translate to fewer showings and lower offers.

Camille cautions sellers against choosing an agent based solely on friendship or discounted fees. Selling a home is financial surgery on your largest asset, and expertise matters.

Takeaway: A full-time, experienced agent who invests in professional marketing and understands local market dynamics is critical to maximizing your sale price.

The Impact

When these mistakes go unaddressed, listings linger, price reductions follow, and sellers lose leverage. Emotion enters the equation, frustration builds, and equity quietly erodes.

In contrast, when sellers price strategically, prepare the home properly, and partner with the right professional, they position themselves to sell faster, negotiate from strength, and move confidently into their next chapter.

Action Steps: Moving from Awareness to Results

1. Detach Emotion from Strategy
   
   

View your home as a market asset. Focus on outcomes, not sentiment.

2. Prepare Before You List
   
   

Address visible maintenance issues and neutralize the space to appeal to the broadest buyer pool.

3. Choose Expertise Over Familiarity 
   
   

Work with a full-time agent who understands your market, invests in marketing, and communicates clearly.

Listen & Learn More

Listen to this episode of The Happy House Hacking Podcast to hear Owen and Camille walk through real-world examples and seller scenarios.